Friday 6 April 2018

A Conundrum: Low Cost Economy or High Income Nation?


Foreign workers take up more than 20% of employment in agriculture, construction and manufacturing sectors (Chart 1).


Chart 1

Of late, foreign workers as a proportion of labour force has trended downward (see Chart 2). Nevertheless, employment of low wage foreign workers allow employers to keep salaries low. As long as firms are engaged on a “race to bottom” on labour costs, it allows employment of cheaper foreign labour vis-a-vis locals. Bank Negara Malaysia (“BNM”) suggests higher living wages for employees. That’s a noble step. But if output/productivity is not any higher, deep seated problems remain unchecked.


Chart 2

There must be a conscious effort by the Government and private sector to move up the chain to a high-income economy. It is driven by productivity improvements, technological edge and technical know-how as cited by BNM. The key elements for that to happen would require some courage:

·       re-introduction of English as a medium of instruction;
·       greater focus on the sciences especially mathematics and physics;
·       an environment of research and innovation (digitalisation, artificial intelligence, big data etc.);
·       a more merit-based system in education, employment and advancement (in career/business);
·       a culture of transparency, accountability and competency; and
·       willingness to “benchmark” with other more developed economies

In each of the above areas, there are several steps that need to be effected and it is only when they come together that Malaysia can truly be a high-income nation. Otherwise, it remains a slogan for politicians and policymakers to debate, discourse and defer. Change is difficult and painful but no progress can be made without them.

Reference: “Low-Skilled Foreign Workers’ Distortions to the Economy” by Ang Jian Wei, Athreya Murugasu, Chai Yi Wei, Economics Department, Bank Negara Malaysia, March 2018

No comments:

Post a Comment